The Week That Was – September 16 to September 23

The Liberal Party is still dealing with allegations of bullying and sexism against women, with Gilmore MP Ann Sudmalis announcing she will not contest her seat at the next election. She’s citing bullying from NSW State MP Gareth Ward and branch stacking in her electorate. This, combined with Julia Bank’s decision not to re-contest her seat, Lucy Gichuhi being placed in an unwinnable spot on the Senate ballot paper in South Australia, Jane Prentice loosing her pre-selection battle earlier this year, and the suspicion that Julie Bishop may not re-contest her seat of Curtin, has the Liberal’s pool of women dropping from its already low numbers. Prime Minister Scott Morrison has announced internal processes to investigate some of these allegations, however there is little information on these internal machinations and women in the party, especially Kelly O’Dwyer, are calling for these investigations to be independent.

Meanwhile there a continuing calls for there to be quotas in the Liberal Party, which most of the men in the Liberal Party don’t think necessary; and Centre Alliance MP Rebekha Sharkie has said that she will withdraw support for the government if they don’t sort out the women’s issue by the Wentworth by-election.

Speaking of the seat of Wentworth, the Liberals have a serious challenger in Independent Dr Kerryn Phelps. Phelps, a Sydney City Councillor, GP and marriage equality campaigner, says that if she wins, she would guarantee supply in order to keep stability. It’s thought Phelps could have a decent chance at the seat, despite Wentworth being held by the Liberals at 17%. This is because a lot of that margin is attributed to Malcolm Turnbull’s personal popularity, and many in the seat of Wentworth are unhappy about how Turnbull was treated. This combined with the fact that the Liberals didn’t choose a female candidate, and Kerryn Phelps is a “local”, could result in a large swing against the Liberal Party. To give context on the whole “local” thing, while there is no law that says you have to live in the electorate you’re representing, in Sydney if you’re not from the area in which you’re running (at least somewhat) you’re not considered to be a “local”. So Dave Sharma, who lives on the North Shore, on the other side of Sydney Harbour to Wentworth, isn’t considered to be a “local”. He is apparently thinking of moving to the electorate, but I have a suspicion that he’d want to wait to see if he’ll actually get the seat.

It got a bit weird though this week, when Scott Morrison didn’t show up for a press conference with Dave Sharma, instead opting to visit a school and talk about school funding. It appears Morrison’s people didn’t tell Sharma he wouldn’t be coming, so Sharma was left standing around, only to have the lectern gate-crashed by Kerryn Phelps, announcing that she would preference the Liberal Party over the Labor Party – doing a backflip on her announcement the day before that she would be putting the Liberals last and Labor ahead of them.

It has been revealed that two media moguls got involved in the Liberal instability during the week of the spill that saw Morrison become Prime Minister. Kerry Stokes, the head of SevenWest Media and Rupert Murdoch, the head of NewsCorp, have been named as getting involved. According to multiple retellings (mostly from Malcolm Turnbull since he headed off to NYC), Turnbull contacted Stokes to ask him whether NewsCorp was actually out to get him, so Stokes obliged and spoke with Murdoch, who confirmed that he had told NewsCorp to editorialise against Malcolm Turnbull and push for Peter Dutton. Funnily enough, much like most of the country and the Liberal Party, Stokes didn’t think Dutton as PM was such a good idea, so instructed editorials be written in favour of Scott Morrison and Julie Bishop. One should take this story with a grain of salt given that it’s been retold quite a few times and has come from a quite bitter Malcolm Turnbull.

The government has announced that they will prevent a number of people with outstanding welfare debts from travelling out of the country. These people have either been accidentally overpaid or they are deliberately defrauding the government, and are yet to pay back their debts despite repeated attempts to get them to pay the money back. The concern is however, that this could end up the same way at that debt collection debacle (which happened nearly two years ago, and I wrote about it earlier here), and there are also concerns about whether these travel bans will only ever be used as a last resort.

The Prime Minister has announced that there will be a Royal Commission into Aged Care. This is partially due to a two-part Four Corners investigation into the industry, and preempted the broadcast of the show by 24 hours. There are no costings or terms of reference yet, but the announcement has garnered support from the opposition, who says that there needs to be better pay for aged care workers and more doctors and nurses. There are calls for there to be nationally legislated minimum staff to patient ratios at aged care homes, like there are at childcare centres, which the industry says isn’t necessary.

The Banking Royal Commission is looking into home insurance this week, with Youi admitting it failed to provide “awesome service” (their words) to two clients. In one case, it took 18 months for Youi to arrange for the repair of a roof damaged after a freak hailstorm in Broken Hill, and in another, Youi is yet to organise the repairs on a home damaged by Cyclone Debbie. Meanwhile, Suncorp has admitted to showing “insufficient compassion” to a long-term customer, and AAMI (owned by Suncorp) have admitted to misleading advertising and failing to cover the complete cost of he repairs of a bushfire ravaged home.

Also this week, there were concerns over the conflicts of interest of Margie McKenzie, a board member of the Marine Park Authority. McKenzie’s husband Col, almost completely owns the Association of Marine Park Tourism Operators, and is a board member of the Reef and Rainforest Research Centre. Both of these organisations received money from the Marine Park Authority, which was funded to a company called Gempearl, which is contracted to eradicate the crown-of-thorns starfish in the Barrier Reef. Gempearl is owned by both McKenzies, meaning that there is a massive conflict of interest on Margie’s part. She has said that she abstained from voting on those issues, however with a change in legislation, she may soon be ineligible to sit on the Marine Park Authority’s board. However, this will no longer be a concern, as McKenzie resigned over the weekend, following the story’s broadcast.

Finally this week, Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe is going to visit Darwin in November for trade meetings. It’s been revealed that Infrastructure Australia refused to give NSW money for their light rail project, as they felt it would have little benefit and would worsen congestion in the Sydney CBD; and the government has increased the maximum penalty for food tampering from 10 years to 15 years, in order to bring the full force of the law upon whoever is putting needles in fruits (Queensland Health says strawberries are safe to buy, just keep cutting them in half). Also, Catholic and Independent schools have earned themselves a $4 billion payment over ten years to transition to the Gonski funding program, closing one battlefront and potentially opening another in the form of public schools.

Tweet of the Week

Things I’ve Been Looking at Online

WA Parliament still has a ban on breastfeeding in the chamber – ABC Online

How leaders work hard at being “normal” – ABC Online

The Two Weeks That Were – September 2 to September 15

Politics returned to relative normalcy over the last fortnight, following a change in Prime Minister, however the Au Pair Affair and another of Peter Dutton’s problems remain. Dutton is still under fire over the thing with the au pairs, after he intervened in the cases of an Italian au pair stopped at Brisbane Airport, and a French au pair stopped in Adelaide Airport. Dutton was asked months ago during question time if he had a personal connection to either of these cases, which he denied was the case. However, the Italian au pair was destined to work for one of Dutton’s former police colleagues, and the French au pair was due to work with the McLachlan family – and AFL boss Gillon McLachlan , who knew Dutton from when he was Sports Minister, alerted Dutton to the situation.

The Senate Inquiry into the au pair affair has seen former Border Force boss Roman Quaedvlieg give evidence against Dutton, saying he intervened in these cases, in one case alleging that Dutton’s chief of staff Craig McLachlan (no relation to the McLachlan family mentioned above) asked Quaedvlieg directly what needed to be done to allow the Italian au pair into Australia. Meanwhile, Dutton is rebuking Quaedvlieg’s account of events, saying they’re untrue because at the time, his Chief of Staff was someone else. Dutton’s accused Roman Quaedvlieg of being a crazed, mentally ill liar and suggested he’s “Labor’s Godwin Grech” – a reference to a former treasury official who went to the liberal party in 2008 or 2009 with false evidence of then-Treasurer Wayne Swan and then-Prime Minister Kevin Rudd abusing the OzCar scheme, which ended up backfiring on then-Opposition Leader Malcolm Turnbull.

It got to a point where Dutton, under parliamentary privilege, said that Quaedvlieg had been sacked for “grooming” a woman thirty years younger than him. Now, first thing is, the woman at the centre of the Quaedvlieg issues was 18, so while a tad creepy with the whole age gap thing, the relationship is totally legal. “Grooming”, which is essentially the act of making it easier to sexually abuse a child, is a crime. In NSW (because that’s where I live), under section 66EB of the Crimes Act 1900, it’s punishable by up to 15 years in prison. Quaedvlieg’s situation is different as the woman in question was at the time an adult, so Dutton’s trying to do some epic damage. Unfortunately for Quaedvlieg, parliamentary privilege is protected speech and so he cannot sue for defamation.

Add to this the further scrutiny of Dutton’s eligibility to even be in Parliament. Dutton and his wife have a trust, mostly controlled by his wife, that owns two childcare centres. It appears that with the recent changes to the way childcare is funded by the government means that the trust directly benefits from the commonwealth, which it didn’t do before. Sources told The Saturday Paper that when the childcare policy came up in Cabinet meetings, while he did make clear his conflict of interest, he didn’t offer to leave the meeting, something many Cabinet members felt he should have done.

Meanwhile Malcolm Turnbull is texting people from New York, telling them Dutton needs to be referred to the High Court.

While Dutton faces his many issues, Prime Minister Scott Morrison has been making deals with the Catholic school system over the “Gonski 2.0” needs-based funding model. In return for going along with the funding program, the government will also give the Catholic school system a transition payment of $4 billion over ten years, which has left Labor unimpressed. He also dragged the parliamentary Liberal Party to a meeting in Albury – the birthplace of the modern Liberal Party – where he attempted to invoke Menzies. The speech also had elements of Christian evangelist preaching – unsurprising given Morrison is the member of a Pentecostal Church.

Morrison also had his first Parliamentary sitting week as PM. It went pretty well, with the exception of his and the party’s inability to explain why the Prime Minister had changed in the first place, and a social media gaffe with this video (Video from the Guardian because Morrison deleted the original from twitter)

The music is Be Faithful by Fatman Scoop – and while this section of the song that Morrison (or more likely a staffer) used is clean, other parts of the song contain sexual references and explicit language (see below).

https://twitter.com/workmanalice/status/1040187121397649408

The only other thing causing the Prime Minister problems is the fact that bullying accusations have continued for the last two weeks. Liberal Senator Lucy Gichuhi is being encouraged to name and shame under parliamentary privilege, and Kelly O’Dwyer has admitted that there was bullying during the week of the spill. It got a bit weird though, because Scott Morrison was being interviewed on 7:30 by Leigh Sales, and he said that Senator Gichuhi had said that in the context of the week of the spill Gichuhi had not been bullied which is in contradiction to her tweet earlier that day:

https://twitter.com/senatorlucy/status/1039317298543177728

So now the residents of my home wonder if the contradiction is the Liberals bullying Senator Gichuhi into silence or if Morrison is using tricky language to say that during the week of the spill Gichuhi was not bullied but she has been bullied generally in her career (as per her tweet) – if that made any sense at all. Julie Bishop has also spoken about the culture in the Liberal Party, and within politics itself, saying much of the behaviour would not be acceptable in any other workplace.

The Wentworth by-election has been set for the 20th of October, with the Liberals party trying to find a candidate that will hold on to the seat for them. Wentworth is currently held on a margin of about 17%, but a lot of that is Malcolm Turnbull’s personal vote, because people like him – Wentworth is one of the most progressive electorates and that combined with the anger at the treatment of Turnbull could see the seat leave Liberal Party hands. Christine Forster, Sydney City Councillor, marriage equality advocate and Tony Abbott’s sister, did not contest the pre-selection battle. However nine others did, until Malcom Turnbull-backed Andrew Bragg stepped out of the race, saying a woman needed to be selected as the candidate. That did not happen, as Dave Sharma, former Ambassador to Israel, was voted as the candidate after a seven hour meeting that ended in the early hours of Friday morning. Sky News reporter Kieran Gilbert was sent a copy of the results by one of the candidates:

There are also concerns about the potential date for the next Federal Election, as there are several factors to take into account. First, the Victorian State election is slated for November 24, 2018, and the NSW State Election is happening on March 23, 2019. Then the government needs to find five clear weeks, preferably without public holidays right in the middle of them, and avoiding school holidays. This means that the last possible date of May 18, 2019 is a bit awkward because the Easter weekend falls on April 19-21, which would be in the middle of a campaign. February and January election dates are not ideal because people tend to take most of their holidays then while their kids aren’t at school. A date in April before easter will result in doubled up campaigning for NSW, which they’d like to avoid as well. I don’t envy the person who has to sit down and figure out the date that works for everyone.

Also this week, the Banking Royal Commission looked at insurance companies and some of their tactics. Freedom Insurance admitted to cold call practices that resulted in a 26-year-old with Downs Syndrome buying life insurance and funeral cover he did not need. His father then fought with the company to cancel the policies, which revealed Freedom Insurance’s practice of not taking no for an answer, with 85% of cancellation requests being unsuccessful. Meanwhile Clearview Insurance has admitted to breaking the law over 300,000 times; CommInsure admitted to using outdated medical definitions; and insurer TAL admitted to having a private investigator trail a customer who was trying to claim for mental health issues which exacerbated the customer’s condition.

Finally this fortnight, the pension age will not rise above 67 for the foreseeable future after the Prime Minister announced the backflip on the Abbott-era policy to increase it to 70; childcare workers across the country went on strike for better pay; there are growing concerns over the health and wellbeing of some young children incarcerated on Nauru – with some apparently close to death; and the GDP rose 0.9% in the June quarter.

Tweets of the Fortnight

https://twitter.com/workmanalice/status/1040352699424755712

Things I’ve Been Looking at Online

Labor’s Muppet Show doorstop – ABC Online

Simon Smart writes about Scott Morrison being a Christian – ABC Online 

An anonymous White House staffer on working against Trump – New York Times

The Week That Was – August 26 to September 1

This week was Scott Morrison’s first week as Prime Minister and he rather quickly announced his cabinet. Mathias Cormann and Peter Dutton, have kept their roles – although Immigration is now no longer part of the Home Affairs portfolio.  A number of cabinet members have also stayed in cabinet or kept their roles, regardless of who they supported during the drama of last week. However, there has been a bit of a reshuffle and two backbenchers have been pulled out of relative obscurity into the ministry, with Melissa Price becoming Environment Minister and Karen Andrews becoming Minister for Industry and Science. Michaelia Cash has been moved sideways to become the Minister for Small Business and Skills, and Kelly O’Dwyer is now Minister for Jobs and Industrial Relations. Steve Ciobo seems to have lost his Trade portfolio to Simon Birmingham, and Dan Tehan is now Education Minister.

Julie Bishop has left the front bench, and will be replaced by Marise Payne as Foreign Minister, so Christopher Pyne is now Defence Minister. The big thing here though is that Bishop has left the ministry and the deputy leadership of the Liberal party after eleven years. One of the most senior and experienced women in the Liberal party is no longer in the ministry, and that’s a heck of a lot of expertise no longer on the front bench. Part of this seems to be because of a group text conversation on WhatsApp between some moderate Liberal MPs and Senators calling themselves “Friends of Stability”. It appears one of them uncovered an alleged plan from the Dutton camp to stick some WA votes behind Bishop in the first round of voting during the spill, in order to knock out Morrison so Dutton would win. Poor Christopher Pyne was left to very respectfully warn Julie Bishop of this plan to use her to get Dutton as PM.

Julie Bishop has said that she will contest her seat of Curtin at the next election, and there are whispers that she could be the next Governor-General as she is respected on both sides of the political divide.

This is not the only issue involving women in the Liberal Party and the spill of last week. Julia Banks, the Member for Chisholm, has announced she will not contest the next election in her marginal Melbourne seat. She cites bullying and sexist behaviour from parliamentary Liberal Party, especially during the week of the spill, where she alleges three MPs and Senators (who are thought to be some of Dutton’s numbers men) engaged in intimidation tactics to try to get her to vote their way.

https://twitter.com/juliabanksmp/status/1034597677017718784

Two other members of parliament, Sarah Henderson MP and Senator Linda Reynolds have also alleged poor behaviour on the part of these “numbers men”, with Henderson apparently being promised a ministry or some other worldly goods, and Reynolds feeling intimidated by the actions of her party – something she spoke about in the Senate to get it into Hansard.

Prime Minister Morrison spent a lot of his first full week as PM not in Canberra. He toured drought affected Queensland at the start of the week and learned more about the effects the drought is having on families. At the end of the week he travelled to Jakarta and met with Indonesian President Joko Widodo. Originally the trip was for Malcolm Turnbull, and many expected it to be postponed after the spill, however, Morrison went over and spent time with Widodo, and they seemed to get on well, and Morrison did represent us well on his first international trip as Prime Minister. Australia is about to sign a Free Trade Agreement with Indonesia, eight years in the making, so the relationship is now more important than ever.

Meanwhile, Peter Dutton is facing criticism over what is being dubbed the “Au Pair Affair”. It’s understood that a couple of years ago, Peter Dutton allowed a 27-year-old French national into the country on a tourist visa, despite the fact that she had admitted to Border Force officials that she would engage in work as an au pair for the McLachlan family. The McLachlan family are well-known South Australian pastoralists and are related to AFL CEO Gillon McLachlan – who knows Dutton from when he was Sports Minister. It appears Gillon McLachlan linked his relatives to Dutton’s office so they could plead the young woman’s case. It’s also understood that he has helped a former cop colleague in the same situation whose potential au pair was detained at Brisbane airport, along with one other au pair – but that last one hasn’t been talked about much.

The Catholic Church has responded to the recommendations from the Child Abuse Royal Commission, saying it will take all but a few of the recommendations on board. They have stated that they won’t be breaking the seal of confession to report child abuse, but they will apply to the Vatican to consider making celibacy a voluntary aspect of being a member of the clergy. Meanwhile, South Australia and the Australian Capital Territory are continuing in their push to make it illegal to not report child abuse revealed to priests in the confessional, against the wishes of the Catholic Church.

Finally this week, Prime Minister Scott Morrison announced Barnaby Joyce will be a Special Envoy for the Drought, and Tony Abbott will be Special Envoy for Indigenous Affairs (which is going down really well amongst the Indigenous community); Chelsea Manning, the US Army intelligence officer who leaked thousands of documents to WikiLeaks, was banned from entering Australia, but she will be allowed to enter New Zealand; the NAPLAN results came out and while Primary school results are improving,  the high school results aren’t as positive; and Australia probably won’t get visited by US President Donald Trump, instead we’ll get a visit from Vice-President Mike Pence.

Tweets of the Week

https://twitter.com/BevanShields/status/1034259584221736960

Things I’ve Been Looking at Online

Annabel Crabb on Julie Bishop’s savage one-liners – ABC Online

Mark Latham’s defamation defence dismissed (it’s awesome) – Federal Court of Australia